Photovoltaic (PV) Solar & Wind Electricity Generation in Spain – A Personal Experience
Before we installed our system, I looked everywhere for tips and knowledge that would help us avoid making the wrong choices. Three years of misery have gone by before we have a reasonable working system. We live in Spain. There is a grant for installation of off-grid strength which method battery-backed electrical systems. The kind of solar panels that heat your water are quite different and we can consider those on another day.
There is quite a lot of help on the web for those seeking “normal” electric strength when they live, as we do, miles away from any mains electric transmission line. But that help tends to be specific to, say, windmills or PV panels, instead of covering the whole layout and most of the articles are from the USA. Firstly, applicable only to Spain, there is a grant “subvencíon” from Prosol, in Andalucía, a government sponsored agency. The grant was, in 2007, for 40% of your solar panel (PV) cost, it has dopped in 2009 to around 30% and you now need two supplies of “green” energy for example solar panels and a wind turbine.
These things matter, our total expenditure on stand-alone electricity has been around €24,000 of which €8,000 has come back by way of government subsidy grant. So, if you live in Spain (or anywhere where there is a government subsidy) number one on you priority list is to be absolutely 100% sure that your supplier qualifies for the grant. Although we ultimately got ours, it took three years of legal battles and our supplier has now gone out of business. Our neighbours (our nearest but they are 3km away) were much smarter, they only paid the (same) installer 60% of the installation price and said they would pay the difference when their government grant came by (it hasn´t).
OK, so you are smarter than us and you have tied your supplier down to a really tight contract which gives you your strength but throws the burden of reclaiming the government grants onto them. What are you going to order in the way of off-grid electric strength? clearly, this depends on where you live. If you don´t live somewhere with a resonable sunshine record, forget PV. Here in the sunniest part of Southern Spain (and we´ve had a horrid winter) we get around 12 kilowatt hours per sunny day from our 2kw range of solar panels. What does this average? This method that we have 12 x 170w panels on our roof which generate (in perfect conditions) just over 2kw of strength which goes into our batteries. The actual strength that they produce depends on the amount of sunlight, the heat of the panels (they produce less electricity when they heat up, which they naturally do in the sunshine), and the length of the day. So, in winter the panels are cold, the day is short and the sun can be dazzling. In summer the panels are hot, the sun is out for ages and the quality of light is often less good – hazy.
We alter the angle of the panels in the Spring and Autumn because this gives us an additional 7% or 150 watts of strength by pointing the panels more towards trajectory of the sun. In the winter, the sun is low on the horizon, in the summer it goes almost right overhead. The angle we use is 25º in summer and 45º in winter. The panels MUST point due (not magnetic) South. Amazingly, the amount of strength produced in a day in the summer or the winter is about the same.
The difference is that in the winter we don´t use much strength, only for lighting and the normal household machines. In summer the swimming pool pump is on for four to six hours a day and this really strains the system. I will come onto batteries, inverters, charge controllers etc. later but I want a reader to understand what they can unprotected to with a €20,000 use on solar PV and wind electric.
When we first looked into this whole matter, there were numerous blogs and websites that told us that we had to save every ounce of energy or we would not be able to live a normal life. The reality is that we run the washing machine (but not tumble dryer), the dish washer, the steam iron, the fridge-freezer, the electric toaster, the Magimix, the breadmaker, the microwave, the de-humidifyer, the water pressure pump and (the worst culprit) the swimming pool pump. So we live a normal life and we have no electricity from the grid.
When we looked into the concept to begin with, websites told us that we couldn´t have fridges or freezers or any form of electric-guzzler. Just not true, you can use your hair dryer because it´s only on for 10 minutes and the big baddie is the swimming pool pump which consumes the same amount but is on for hours. To sum up, for an outlay of €16k (after the grant), you can have an electric system better than the mains (at the minimum in Spain where it is forever failing and “browning out”). Here in Andalucia, the average electric bill is €250 every two months to include Winter Heating and Summer Cooling. This adds up to around €1,500 a year, none of which is payable for a PV system. This seems a realistic payback timescale to me of 10 to 12 years (or shorter if the price of electricity increases).
Before you buy, just be certain of all your costs. Your installer will be going by the normal wholesale channels in Spain and you will be paying retail prices. Some items are so much cheaper from the UK that, grant or not, you have to buy them there and get them couriered to Spain. ALWAYS check prices on eBay before you buy anything.
Batteries. Assuming you have a largeish installation you will either be running a 24v or 48v system. Which to choose? We have 48v which method 24 x 2v batteries. A 24v system which had the same battery capacity would have 12 batteries of 2v but with each battery double the size. Why would you choose one over the other? Well, my opinion is that 48v is more elegant but there again there is more kit obtainable for 24v. How on Earth can you understand this? A four cylinder car engine is perfectly good but an eight cylinder is better, although more expensive. I don´t think it matters massively which you choose, 48v will cost you a little more so if you´re on a budget go 24v but the difference isn´t huge.
Batteries. What is the only important thing about batteries? That they are NEVER discharged beyond their moderate value. So, we have 24 x 2 volt batteries making a moderate 48 volts. These batteries will truly charge up to around 60 volts, depending on temperature. This “overcharging” is called “absorbing” and cleans the rule plates. After a associate of hours the charge controller will drop the voltage to around 54 volts which is called floating. If your batteries release lower than their moderate value, 48 volts in our case, they will be ruined, meaning that they will never be able to store a complete charge again. Please understand this it is the most important fact in all your solar strength installation, if you learn nothing else from this, please remember to NEVER let your batteries release below thier moderate voltage. Halve all the figures for a 24v system.
Batteries need to be topped up with distilled water, nothing else. So, as long as you never let them fall below their moderate voltage, don´t worry about anything other than keeping them topped up and keeping the connections well greased to keep out the oxygen which might corrode them. When there is no sun and no wind and you need to top them up, you will have to use a generator. typically, you would have a large enough battery bank to survive three days without sun but during those three days you do not use the swimming pool pump, the washing machine, your hairdryer etc. You can nevertheless use the lighting and a few luxuries like the TV but shared sense tells you that the more you take out of your batteries the sooner they get close to 48 volts and then you have to act.
Generators are dirty and noisy and consume expensive petrol or diesel so the less you use them the better. However, the biggest cost of a generator is the machine itself. A proper generator is powered by a multi-cylinder water cooled engine and will cost you around €5,000 new. Correctly serviced, this should last you a lifetime. At the other end of the extent are little, Chinese made, single cylinder, air cooled engines. We paid €2,000 for our first diesel one with electric start and sound-proofed box and we are on our third which cost less than €200 and is the most basic I could find. However much you pay for these “cheap” generators, do not expect them to last 500 hours, already if you change the oil every 100 hours and clean the air filter every 50 hours. That is why we buy the cheapest possible.
NEVER lend your generator to anyone else. The reason that they want to borrow yours is that they have broken theirs and they will return yours in the same state. When they return it, it might appear to work but they will have changed the speed at which the engine runs and this alters the output voltage of the generator. The generator is often wired into your inverter (see below) which is the single most expensive piece of kit in your whole system.
If the voltage coming out of your generator is too high it will blow up your inverter, which cost us €5,000, and the guarantee will not be valid unless you are really lucky, as we were, twice! So, my recommendation to you is not to wire the generator into your inverter but to use a stand-alone battery charger. Ours was designed to recharge a fork-lift truck so it knows to turn itself off when the batteries are complete, although I can’t imagine anyone using a generator for that long.
The inverter turns your DC battery-stored electricity into AC voltage at 230v (or 120v in the USA) which method that ordinary machines that you buy in the high-street shops will work. If your generator is wired into your inverter the mains kind strength produced by the generator can be diverted into the house when not powering the batteries and, in our example, this caused endless small strength surges as the inverter switched our electric supply between generator and battery, another reason to use a stand-alone battery charger. The inverter is a large and very heavy box because, other than some delicate and complicated electronics, it contains a wire that truly converts your battery strength to mains-kind electricity. As stated above, it can be really expensive and for this reason some people use more than one. Two small ones are far cheaper than one large one but we opted for a single one that produces 5kw continuous (with a maximum load of 10kw) on the basis that 5kw is represented by the diswasher, washing machine and swimming pool pump running together so you don’t want the whole system to overload when the fridge cuts in. Ours is produced by Mastervolt in Holland and they are such a joy to deal with, thank you Mastervolt. However, many people have a small inverter for the lighting circuit and a larger one for the ring-main.
When our inverter went wrong last time, I installed a 48v computer UPS (uninterruptable strength suppy) in its place until it returned. This cost me (second hand and without the battery, I’ve got batteries) less than €100 and produced around 2.5kw of perfect strength. Luckily, I don’t really have to think about it but if I was starting over I might well have a bank of UPSs instead of a single inverter, however you would need to wire the house differently as you cannot mix the AC current from different supplies.
The next most important piece of kit (other than the panels) is your charge controller. Here, I can recommend the Outback MX60 (one of only three names that I will recommend to you in this article). The Outback takes the strength from the solar panels and uses it to charge the batteries. The MX60 is limited to 60 Amps output strength (unless you read the manual and work out how to get it up to 70) and volts x amps = watts (strength). consequently in a 48v system strength output from the MX60 is twice what it is in a 24v system, and this could be another deciding factor for you in choice of voltage as for a 2kw panel range you would need two MX60s if you are on 24v. There are three really clever features on the MX60, which is configurable for 12, 24 or 48v output. Firstly, it will take a much higher input voltage than its output voltage (but only up to 130v maximum). This method that we have connected three 24v solar panels in series to produce a moderate 72v output and an effective output much higher, ours has peaked at 118v. The higher the voltage, the less strength is lost in the wires beween the panels and the batteries. As we have 12 panels, there are four sets of three with the four sets connected in paralel. Then the MX60 benefits from MPPT, maximum strength point tracking, which wrings a little more strength from those expensive solar panels. Lastly, the MX60 comes with an optional external thermometer which attaches to a battery and it consequently alters the charging of your battery bank to optimise it for temperature, consequently extending the life of your batteries.
Solar panels are a commodity and they are the only things backed by a long guarantee. The Spanish government insists that they should be guaranteed to produce 80% of their rated output after 25 years. The first set that we got were branded Suntaics, a German company who are among the least helpful people you could ever come across. These panels went wrong within six months as connecting wires within them melted. My recommendation is to pay a little more and get a really well known brand from a company that will be around in 25 years to honour their guarantee. Since installing ours into a frame that hinges at the bottom to allow us to change the angle at different times of the year, I need at the minimum one other strong man to help me raise or lower them. My recommendation would be to mount the frame on a central pipe, like a scaffold tube, which could be rotated to change the angle and would require very little effort compared to physically lifting the set of six panels which are fitted in a single frame.
Solar panels give off electricity, called photovoltaic or PV, when they receive light and they can be wired together in series, as seen above, to produce higher voltage. I know this may sound a little simple, but you can only charge your 48 volt battery if you are inputting more than 48 volts. And remember that in its “absorbing” stage, your battery might get up to 60 volts before settling down and “floating” at 54 volts or so (this changes with the temperature and with the kind of battery). consequently, you can’t charge a 48 volt battery from a single 24 volt solar panel, you need at the minimum two wired together. Just to confuse you further, a 24v solar panel will produce up to 40v or more depending of temerature and amount of sunlight! This concept is vital when we consider the windmill.
We only have a windmill to qualify for the grant. Having said that, we wouldn’t be without it now. It was cheap and manufactured by FuturEnergy from the UK who are extremely helpful. You can get the whole thing from eBay for less than £1,000, windmill, charge controller, stop switch and dump loads for something that outputs a moderate 1kw (our solar panels are rated at 2kw but rarely produce more than 1750w because they produce less as they heat up). The FuturEnergy windmill outputs a moderate 48v, another plus for choosing a 48v system.
So when it blows a gale, typically when the sun is not shining, we don’t have to use the generator to charge the batteries. However, most of the time, the windmill is useless because the voltage it produces depends on the speed at which it is turning (I only found this out by disconnecting it from the batteries which you are not meant to do). If the batteries are typically at around 49 to 50 volts at night or when there is no sun, which is a “comfortable” level, then the windmill cannot charge them unless it is producing more than 49 volts. I haven’t measured the wind speed at which this happens but it is only when there is so much wind that it is uncomfortable being outside – I know that that is subjective but is important that you don’t think you’re going to get a continued source of electricity unless you live in a very windy place. Comparing the windmill’s input with other people’s experiences, I would say that it is very useful but you would never get to float the batteries from it, already if you had 48 hours of continued 25mph wind, while a associate of sunny days will easily float the batteries. Better to rely on the windmill as something that might avoid you having to use the generator on a day without sun.
I had the tower for the windmill made at the local blacksmith’s of which there are plenty in Spain. It consists of one and a bit scaffold tubes welded together to form a 7.5 metre pole on a hinged base and supported by 5mm steel wires from four steel plates bolted to a concrete base. At first, there was only one wire from each plate to the top of the scaffold tube but the pipe would definitely have buckled without a second wire to sustain it half way up and keep it stiff.
How to give a summary of our three year adventure in different energy in Spain? The first piece of advice is to trust no one, our original installer has gone out of business and didn’t know what they were doing anyway. The more you learn yourself, the less likely you are to make a costly mistake. Now that it is all over, I would not choose the option of installing a serious on-need diesel generator which seemed the better way for a long time. However, I would do without the government grant and would buy all the items that I need (other than the batteries which really need to be delivered to you from the factory) from eBay and fit them myself. This would save more money than the grant provided and, although electricity is very dangerous and I recommend you use a qualified electrician to connect up your system, the whole concept is very easy and just takes a little shared sense. Fear of the unknown leads us to consult an ‘expert’ and, while undoubtedly there are well qualified off-grid engineers out there somewhere, neither we nor our neighbours have found one however and we have consulted many ‘experts’.